Why it matters when your symptoms started
One of the biggest differences between homeopathy and many other approaches to healthcare is that homeopaths don't only look at what symptoms someone has.
We also want to understand:
What happened before those symptoms appeared?
What changed?
What was the trigger?
What was the experience that shifted someone from feeling well to feeling unwell?
In homeopathy, this is often referred to as the root cause of the presenting symptom(s).
Symptoms tell a story
When someone comes to see me, they may say:
"I need help with anxiety."
"My eczema keeps coming back."
"My migraines are getting worse."
"My digestion hasn't been the same since I was ill."
Of course, these symptoms are important. But in homeopathy, we are interested in the story behind them. Sometimes the most important clue isn't the symptom itself, but what happened before the symptom began.
For example:
Did your anxiety begin after a frightening experience?
Did your grief become overwhelming after a significant loss?
Did your health change after a major disappointment?
Did your symptoms start after a period of intense stress or exhaustion?
Did your body change after a particular illness, injury or life event?
These details can completely change the direction of a homeopathic case.
The importance of "ailments from" in homeopathy
Homeopathic repertories contain specific rubrics around the cause of illness, often written as "ailments from."
These rubrics reflect the idea that the event that preceded an illness can be an important part of understanding the person and selecting a remedy.
For example, someone experiencing anxiety after a frightening event may present very differently from someone whose anxiety developed after years of overwork and emotional exhaustion.
Someone struggling after a bereavement may need a different approach from someone whose symptoms appeared after a relationship breakdown or a major disappointment.
The diagnosis might look similar, but the story behind it is different.
This is why homeopaths don't simply prescribe for "anxiety," "eczema" or "migraine."
We look for the individual pattern. If we know the root cause of the symptoms, it can often lead us to the most effective remedy to get your health back in balance.
Finding the opening to a case
Homeopath Robin Murphy highlighted the importance of understanding the root cause when taking a case. When the cause is known, it can often provide an important starting point for the initial prescription.
In practice, this means that sometimes the most valuable information a client gives me isn't:
"My anxiety is a 7 out of 10."
It might actually be:
"My anxiety started after my divorce."
"My migraines began after a bereavement."
"I haven't felt like myself since that frightening experience."
That piece of information can become the doorway into understanding the whole case.
A real life example
Imagine two people who both come to see me with digestive problems.
The first person says:
"My digestion changed after years of chronic stress. I was constantly rushing, looking after everyone else and ignoring my own needs."
The second person says:
"My digestion changed after a period of intense grief when I lost someone close to me."
The physical symptom may be the same, but the journey that led there is completely different.
In homeopathy, that journey matters.
Why consultations are so detailed
This is why a homeopathic consultation can feel very different from a typical appointment.
I don't just want to know:
"What is your diagnosis?"
I want to know:
"When did this begin?"
"What was happening in your life at the time?"
"What makes it better or worse?"
"How does it affect you emotionally?"
"What makes your experience unique?"
Sometimes the smallest detail can be the missing piece of the puzzle.
The body remembers experiences
Life events affect us.
A major loss, a frightening experience, a period of prolonged stress or a significant change can leave an impression on our physical and emotional wellbeing. The body holds these emotions and if we don’t deal with them, they will eventually remind us they’re there through physical symptoms.
Homeopathy recognises that our health is not separate from our experiences.
We are whole people, not a collection of separate symptoms.
The takeaway
Your symptoms are important, but your story is equally important.
The question isn't only:
"What are you experiencing?"
It is also:
"What happened that led you here?"
Because sometimes the key to understanding a case isn't found in the symptom itself, but in the story that came before it.
If you would like to learn more about how homeopaths take a case and why we ask so many questions, read my blog:
Why I ask you such seemingly random questions in a homeopathy consultation
Get weekly homeopathy insights and tips into your box.
Interested to know how homeopathy can help you? Let’s have a free 15 minute chat!